Navigating the Impact of Severance Packages on Long-Term Disability Benefits in Ontario

Understanding the Relationship Between Severance and long-term disability Benefits

In Ontario, severance pay and long-term disability benefits are two critical financial supports that employees may rely on following job loss. However, the interaction between these two forms of compensation is not always straightforward. Many employees receiving long-term disability benefits are unaware that accepting a severance package could impact their eligibility for continued disability payments.

Under the Employment Standards Act, 2000 (ESA), terminated employees are entitled to termination pay and, in some cases, severance pay. However, this legislation does not specifically address how severance impacts long-term disability benefits, leaving room for interpretation by employers and insurers. Many long-term disability policies contain clauses stating that severance pay will be deducted from disability benefits, reducing or eliminating payouts.

Moreover, some insurers argue that by accepting severance, an employee is no longer considered “employed” under the long-term disability policy, thereby disqualifying them from further benefits. This creates a precarious situation where employees may be forced to choose between severance and continued disability payments.

The Financial Risks of Accepting Severance While on long-term disability

A major challenge for employees is that severance packages are often structured in a lump sum payment. For individuals relying on long-term disability benefits, this may create the illusion of income continuation, leading insurers to cease payments. Some long-term disability policies explicitly state that severance offsets the amount an individual is entitled to receive in long-term disability benefits, while others remain ambiguous.

Additionally, taxation plays a role in this decision-making process. Lump sum severance payments may be taxed at a higher rate than ongoing long-term disability benefits, potentially reducing an employee’s net income. Employees should work with an employment lawyer in Toronto to determine the financial implications before accepting severance.

Legal Precedents and Recent Developments

Ontario case law has provided some updated guidance on this issue. Dufault v. Ignace (Township), 2024 ONCA 915, is a recent case that has significant implications for employees navigating severance and LTD entitlements. In this case, the Ontario Court of Appeal upheld the lower court’s finding that a “for cause” termination provision in an employee’s fixed-term contract was unenforceable due to non-compliance with the ESA. The court emphasized that termination clauses must align with ESA standards; failure to do so renders such clauses invalid. This ruling underscores the necessity for employers to draft termination provisions that meet statutory requirements to avoid potential liabilities.

Additionally, Ontario case law has provided further guidance on the relationship between severance and LTD benefits. In Brito v. Canac Kitchens, 2012 ONCA 61, the Ontario Court of Appeal ruled that the employer in that case could not deduct LTD benefits from wrongful dismissal damages. This decision underscores the importance of employment contracts in determining entitlements. Employees should carefully review their severance offers and insurance policies to understand their rights.

Additionally, recent trends indicate that employers and insurers are increasingly scrutinizing severance agreements to minimize payouts. Employees who believe their severance or LTD benefits are being unfairly calculated should seek legal advice from a long-term disability lawyer in Toronto.

Protecting Your Rights: Steps to Take

To ensure you receive fair compensation when facing job loss and disability:

• Review your employment and long-term disability policies: Understand the fine print regarding severance and long-term disability offsets.
• Negotiate severance terms carefully: Employers may be open to structuring payments in a way that minimizes impact on long-term disability benefits.
• Seek legal guidance: A lawyer from employment law firms in Toronto can ensure your rights are protected and that you are not unfairly disadvantaged by a severance agreement.
• Appeal Denied Claims: If an insurer denies long-term disability benefits after severance, seek legal representation to challenge the decision.

Employees facing job loss and disability should act proactively to avoid unintended consequences. If you need assistance, consult a long-term disability lawyer in Toronto to review your severance package and long-term disability claim.

How Unified LLP Can Help

Whether you’re a worker facing unfair treatment or an employer striving to comply with evolving regulations, Unified LLP is here to help. Our experienced team provides:

• Guidance on workplace rights.
• Representation in disputes related to wrongful dismissal or unpaid wages.
• Support for employers managing legal challenges.

We offer an employment lawyer free consultation to assess your case and provide tailored solutions.

Contact Unified LLP Today

For expert legal advice on issues related to severance, long-term disability benefits, or any workplace matter, contact Unified LLP. Whether you need an employment lawyer near me or assistance with professional discipline, we’re here to protect your rights and interests.

Contact us to book your free consultation today and take the first step toward reclaiming your rights in the workplace.

Are you a member of a union? Book a free 30 minute consultation on our Union Portal today.