Why You Should Never Sign a Severance Package Without Legal Advice
Losing your job is stressful enough. Then a termination letter arrives with a severance offer, a release, and a deadline that may be only a few days away. It is tempting to sign a severance package quickly and move on. In Ontario, though, that first offer is often built around the legal minimum, not what you may actually be owed. Once you sign, you usually give up the right to ask for more. This guide explains what a severance package really contains, what employers commonly leave out, and why a short review before you sign can make a meaningful difference.
What Happens When You Sign a Severance Package
When you sign a severance package, you typically accept the offer as full settlement of any claims against your employer. The document that does this is the release.
A full and final release is a legal promise not to sue your former employer over your employment or the way it ended. Releases are often broad. Depending on the wording, they can cover wrongful dismissal claims, unpaid bonuses or commissions, and in some cases human rights complaints.
Ontario courts generally enforce signed releases. Setting one aside is difficult and usually requires proof of something serious, such as duress. In practical terms, your signature ends the negotiation.
Minimum Entitlements vs. What You May Actually Be Owed
Most Ontario employees have two layers of entitlement when they are let go without cause: statutory minimums under the Employment Standards Act, 2000 (ESA), and common law reasonable notice. Many first offers only cover the first layer.
Employment Standards Act minimums
Under the ESA, employees with at least three months of service are generally entitled to notice or termination pay, ranging from one week to a maximum of eight weeks. Employees with five or more years of service may also qualify for severance pay of up to 26 weeks if the employer has a global payroll of at least $2.5 million, or if 50 or more employees lose their jobs within six months because all or part of the business permanently closed. The Ontario government’s guide to termination of employment sets out the full rules and exceptions.
Common law reasonable notice
Unless a valid employment contract limits you to the ESA minimums, you are generally also entitled to reasonable notice at common law. Courts consider factors such as your age, length of service, the nature of your role, and how long it is likely to take you to find comparable work. The result is often far higher than the ESA amount.
| ESA minimums | Common law reasonable notice | |
|---|---|---|
| Who sets it | Ontario legislation | Courts, or negotiation between the parties |
| Typical range | 1 to 8 weeks of notice or pay, plus up to 26 weeks of severance pay if eligible | Depends on your circumstances; often several months, and in most cases up to about 24 months, sometimes more |
| Can you give it up by signing? | No. Your employer must pay it whether or not you sign | Yes. A signed release usually ends this claim |
You Do Not Have to Sign to Receive Your ESA Pay
Some people sign because they worry they will otherwise get nothing. That worry is usually misplaced. Your employer must pay your ESA termination pay, and any ESA severance pay you qualify for, whether or not you sign a release. These amounts are due by the later of seven days after your employment ends or your next regular pay day.
What is usually conditional on signing is the extra money offered above the minimum. That is exactly the part worth having reviewed.
Six Things to Check Before You Sign a Severance Package
- Your termination clause. Many contracts try to limit you to ESA minimums. Ontario courts have found a large number of these clauses unenforceable, especially since the Court of Appeal’s 2020 decision in Waksdale v. Swegon North America. If your clause fails, common law notice may apply. Learn more about how courts assess termination clauses.
- Benefits continuation. The ESA requires benefit coverage to continue through the statutory notice period. Confirm whether health, dental, and life insurance continue, and for how long.
- Bonuses, commissions, and stock options. Variable pay you would have earned during the notice period may form part of what you are owed. Packages frequently leave it out.
- Lump sum or salary continuance. Salary continuance pays you over time and may stop or shrink when you find new work. A lump sum offers certainty. The better option depends on your job prospects.
- Disability and insurance coverage. If you are ill, injured, or receiving disability benefits, losing group coverage can have serious consequences. See how severance pay can interact with long-term disability benefits.
- The scope of the release. Check exactly which claims you are giving up and whether you are agreeing to confidentiality, non-disparagement, or non-solicitation terms.
Deadlines, Employment Insurance, and Timing Pressure
Severance offers often arrive with a short deadline. That deadline reflects your employer’s preference, not a legal limit on your rights. You can usually ask for reasonable extra time to get advice, and many employers agree. The legal limitation period for most wrongful dismissal claims in Ontario is two years under the Limitations Act, 2002.
Do not let negotiations delay your Employment Insurance application. The federal government advises that you apply for EI regular benefits right away, because applying more than four weeks after your last day of work may cost you benefits. Severance and pay in lieu of notice can affect when EI payments begin, so report them accurately.
How Legal Advice Can Change the Outcome
An employment lawyer can compare your offer with what a court would likely award, test whether your contract limits your rights, and spot missing items such as benefits or bonus. Many severance disputes are resolved through negotiation without going to court.
Advice also helps you avoid costly mistakes, such as signing a release that waives a claim you did not know you had. And if the offer turns out to be fair, you can sign with confidence instead of wondering.
The Bottom Line
A severance package is a settlement offer, not a final verdict on what you are owed. Before you sign a severance package, make sure you understand the release, know the difference between ESA minimums and common law notice, and check what may be missing. Because your statutory minimums are owed regardless, a short pause to get advice rarely puts that money at risk.
If you have received a termination letter, Unified LLP’s wrongful dismissal lawyers in Toronto can review your offer and explain your options before you decide.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I negotiate a severance package in Ontario?
Yes. A severance package is usually an opening offer, not a final one. Employees can respond with a counteroffer, often through a lawyer, that reflects common law reasonable notice, lost benefits, and variable pay. Whether more is available depends on your contract, your role, your length of service, and other circumstances, so the outcome varies from case to case.
What happens if I refuse to sign my severance package?
You still receive your Employment Standards Act minimums, because your employer must pay them whether or not you sign. You may lose access to any extra amount offered in exchange for the release. Not signing also preserves your right to pursue a wrongful dismissal claim, which generally must be started within two years.
How long do I have to sign a severance agreement?
The deadline in the offer letter is set by your employer, and it is not a legal cut-off for your rights. You can ask for more time to get legal advice, and many employers allow it. Separately, most wrongful dismissal claims in Ontario must be started within two years under the Limitations Act, 2002.
Is severance pay the same as termination pay in Ontario?
No. Under the ESA, termination pay replaces the notice you were owed, up to eight weeks. Severance pay is a separate payment of up to 26 weeks for eligible employees with five or more years of service at larger employers or in qualifying closures. Common law reasonable notice is a third, separate entitlement decided by the courts.


